If you’ve noticed homes sitting on the market for longer than expected in Sonoma County, you’re not alone. You might even be one of those homeowners wondering why your home, with all its charm and appeal, hasn’t sold yet. Many assume it’s a matter of pricing or staging, but there’s much more to the story. As the #1 real estate team in Sonoma County, we’ve worked with all kinds of sellers and buyers, witnessing firsthand the unique factors influencing our market. Here, we’re sharing five reasons why homes aren’t selling and how you can overcome these challenges to turn your listing into a success.
Imagine you’re a buyer searching for a home in a quiet neighborhood in Windsor. You find a beautiful property on 224 Lea St., perfectly priced and exactly what you had in mind. Then you hear about a proposed 68-acre casino and resort in the area, featuring 2,500 gaming machines, a luxury hotel, and a suite of restaurants. Even though the Koi Nation casino project isn’t yet approved, the mere possibility of its construction raises questions about traffic, noise, and the character of the neighborhood.
This is exactly what happened to 224 Lea St., which eventually sold only after a significant price reduction. Developments like this one can be polarizing—some people love the idea of new entertainment and economic opportunities, while others worry about how it might change their lifestyle.
Advice for Sellers: If your property is near an upcoming development, don’t let potential buyers discover it on their own. Working with a local agent who is aware of these projects and can communicate both the potential positives and negatives will be invaluable. Together, you can address these questions up front, allowing buyers to feel informed and reassured about the future of their investment.
Let’s look at 6063 Hyland Way, a beautiful three-bedroom home with a spacious workshop and a cozy guest unit. It’s a fantastic property that would seem ideal for any family. However, there’s a catch: the home has a one-bedroom septic system. For those used to city living, the significance of this might not be immediately clear, but in the world of rural real estate, septic systems are critical.
For many buyers, the mention of a “septic system limitation” can conjure up visions of costly upgrades or restrictions on future use. With a three-bedroom layout but a one-bedroom septic system, this property languished on the market for over 200 days.
Advice for Sellers: Transparency is key. If your property has a septic system that may seem limiting, don’t shy away from discussing it. Working with a realtor who understands these rural quirks and can clearly explain to buyers how the system functions—and what it would take to upgrade if necessary—can prevent misunderstandings and help your listing shine.
In many parts of Sonoma County, water isn’t just a utility; it’s a lifeline. For properties in regions like Mill Creek Road in Healdsburg, access to water can be a dealbreaker. These areas can be prone to seasonal water shortages, with some homes even requiring water to be trucked in. Drilling a new well isn’t a straightforward solution, either—some homeowners have spent $10,000 on drilling only to come up empty-handed.
Consider a family envisioning their dream home in Healdsburg, only to learn that maintaining a consistent water supply might require storage tanks or expensive hauling. It’s an unfortunate reality that can cast a shadow over an otherwise idyllic property.
Advice for Sellers: If your property is in a water-limited area, be upfront. Outline current water solutions and highlight any recent upgrades or practical ways buyers can manage the situation. Honesty about water limitations helps set realistic expectations, especially for buyers unaccustomed to the challenges of rural living.
Picture this: a stunning Sonoma County home, complete with luxury finishes and breathtaking views, sits on the market longer than expected. The reason? Something as intangible as an address containing the number “13” or a history of a death on the property. In many cultures, superstitions play a significant role in decision-making. For example, some buyers, especially those from Asian backgrounds, might view a home associated with death as holding “negative energy,” making it a non-starter.
In California, sellers are required to disclose if a death has occurred on a property within the last three years. For many buyers, this disclosure can be a dealbreaker, and these deeply ingrained beliefs are often non-negotiable.
Advice for Sellers: A creative solution may help. Some sellers choose to conduct rituals or cleansing ceremonies to address energy concerns, while others emphasize the property’s appeal to less superstitious buyers. Understanding cultural sensitivities and adjusting your marketing can go a long way toward attracting the right buyer.
5. Lack of Connectivity: A Dealbreaker in Today’s Remote Work Era
Connectivity has quickly evolved from a luxury to a necessity. Today, reliable internet and cell service are essential, especially as more people work from home. Rural areas in Sonoma County are no strangers to connectivity challenges. Properties in dense, wooded areas may struggle to receive Starlink signals or lack sufficient bandwidth for everyday needs. In one instance, a buyer passed on a property because trees blocked the signal needed for NFL Sunday Ticket—a seemingly small detail but one that affected the sale.
Advice for Sellers: If connectivity is an issue, it’s best to be transparent and explore solutions, if possible. Outline the options for internet service and get details and costs for the service, Making buyers aware of the options early in the process can help avoid surprises later.
Selling a home in Sonoma County can come with unique challenges, but understanding these factors is the first step toward turning them into selling points. Our team has helped over 70 families in the past year alone, with nearly $80 million in transactions. Whether you’re buying, selling, or considering an investment property, our local expertise is here to guide you through the process.
Selling your home shouldn’t be a mystery. By working with a team that understands Sonoma County inside and out, you can confidently navigate the market and make informed decisions.
Ready to talk? Let’s connect to discuss your goals and how we can turn your listing into the next Sonoma County success story.
Sign in with your email address
Enter your email address
